In September 2009, a mother facing a court-ordered custody transfer packed up her seven-year-old daughter and disappeared. With help from a network of supporters, Lisa Miller crossed into Canada and flew to Nicaragua. She left behind her former civil-union partner, Janet Jenkins, who had helped pay for the IVF that brought their daughter into the world. Jenkins would not see the girl again for more than a decade. Miller surrendered at the U.S. Embassy only in January 2021, after her daughter turned 18.
Miller-Jenkins is an extreme case. But the forces behind it show up in many same-sex divorces: a fight over who counts as a "real" parent, years of partnership the law did not recognize, and family or community pressure that pours fuel on the conflict.
The legal landscape has changed a great deal. Maryland and the District of Columbia now treat same-sex marriages and divorces exactly like any other. Yet LGBTQ+ couples still face issues that rarely come up in other divorces. Here is what you need to know if your separation has turned high-conflict.
Maryland Once Refused to Grant a Same-Sex Divorce
It was not long ago that getting divorced was itself a battle. Jessica Port and Virginia Anne Cowan married in California in 2008 and later separated. Both wanted a divorce. Yet in 2010 a Prince George's County judge refused to grant one, ruling that recognizing their marriage would violate Maryland public policy.
In Port v. Cowan (2012), Maryland's highest court unanimously reversed. It held that a valid out-of-state same-sex marriage must be recognized in Maryland and is entitled to a divorce like any other. Maryland's own marriage equality law took effect in January 2013, and the U.S. Supreme Court's 2015 Obergefell v. Hodges decision made marriage equality national.
How Divorce Works Today in Maryland and DC
Maryland. Since October 1, 2023, Maryland is a fully no-fault state. Under Family Law § 7-103, you may divorce on one of three grounds: six-month separation, irreconcilable differences, or mutual consent with a signed settlement agreement. Fault grounds like adultery and cruelty, and "limited divorce," are gone. Spouses can even be considered separated while living under one roof if they lead separate lives. If the grounds arose outside Maryland, one spouse must have lived in the state for six months before filing.
District of Columbia. Since January 26, 2024, DC requires no separation period at all. A divorce may be granted when one or both spouses say they no longer wish to stay married (D.C. Code § 16-904). One spouse must be a DC resident for six months before filing (§ 16-902). DC also has a special provision for couples who married in DC but live where their marriage cannot be dissolved.
The takeaway: in both jurisdictions, a spouse cannot block a divorce by refusing to cooperate. In a high-conflict case, the real fight is over children, money, and safety.
Flashpoint #1: "You're Not Really the Parent"
The most painful fights in same-sex divorces are often about parentage. Usually only one spouse is biologically related to the child. In a bitter case, that spouse may argue the other has no rights at all.
That is what happened in Maryland's landmark Conover v. Conover (2016). The couple had a son, Jaxon, conceived with donor sperm through a fertility clinic. The non-biological parent, Michael Conover, never adopted Jaxon. After the couple split, a Washington County court denied Michael's request for visitation. The court relied on a 2008 precedent, Janice M. v. Margaret K., which refused to recognize "de facto parents."
Maryland's highest court unanimously overruled Janice M. It held that a de facto parent has standing to seek custody or visitation without first proving the biological parent unfit. To qualify, a person generally must show that:
- The legal parent consented to and fostered the parent-like relationship.
- The person lived with the child in the same household.
- The person took on real parental duties without expecting payment.
- The relationship lasted long enough to create a bonded, dependent relationship.
Later cases refined the rule. In E.N. v. T.R. (2021), the court held that when a child already has two legal parents, both must consent to the third person's parental role.
Maryland's parentage statute. Since 2019, Maryland law (Estates & Trusts § 1-208) has recognized as a parent a spouse or partner who consents to a child's conception through assisted reproduction, regardless of gender. A married non-birth parent can also rely on the marital presumption.
DC's de facto parent statute. DC writes the doctrine into law. Under D.C. Code § 16-831.01, a person who lived with the child, held themselves out as a parent with the legal parent's agreement, and took on full parental responsibility may qualify. A person who proves de facto parent status by clear and convincing evidence is treated as a parent in custody and support cases (§ 16-831.03).
Practical advice: Do not rely on the birth certificate alone. Many family-law attorneys still recommend a confirmatory (second-parent) adoption or court parentage judgment. A court judgment is the strongest protection if you or your child move to a less friendly state.
Flashpoint #2: Custody When Parents Can't Cooperate
Once both spouses are recognized as parents, custody is decided by the same standard used for every family: the best interests of the child. Maryland and DC apply it differently.
Maryland. As of October 1, 2025, Maryland judges must weigh 16 best-interest factors codified in Family Law § 9-201 (enacted as House Bill 1191). There is no presumption for or against joint custody. Several factors speak directly to high-conflict families, including each parent's ability to communicate and cooperate and their willingness to support the child's relationship with the other parent. Maryland Rule 9-205.2 also lets a court appoint a parenting coordinator in high-conflict cases. Court-ordered custody mediation is not required where there is a genuine issue of abuse, including coercive control.
District of Columbia. DC starts from a rebuttable presumption that joint custody is in the child's best interest (D.C. Code § 16-914). That presumption flips when a judge finds, by a preponderance of the evidence, an intrafamily offense, child abuse, or parental kidnapping.
What Miller-Jenkins teaches. After the couple's Vermont civil union was dissolved, Lisa Miller received primary custody and Janet Jenkins received visitation. Miller repeatedly blocked those visits. Courts in Vermont and Virginia fought over jurisdiction, but both state supreme courts ruled that Vermont's orders controlled. In 2009, a Vermont judge transferred custody to Jenkins because of the ongoing interference. Miller fled instead. A Virginia pastor who helped her was convicted in 2012 of aiding international parental kidnapping and sentenced to 27 months.
Applied in Maryland or DC, the lesson is the same:
- Gatekeeping backfires. A parent who shuts the other out can lose custody. Maryland's factors weigh willingness to foster the other relationship, and in DC parental kidnapping defeats the joint custody presumption.
- Jurisdiction rules. Moving a child across state lines to get a "better" court rarely works. Maryland and DC both follow the Uniform Child Custody Jurisdiction and Enforcement Act, which generally keeps the case in the child's home state.
- Outside influences matter. When relatives or communities who disapprove of the relationship push one parent to cut the other out, the court focuses on the child, not their views.
Flashpoint #3: "We Were Together 20 Years, Not Five"
Many same-sex couples spent years, even decades, together before the law let them marry. In a divorce, the official wedding date can sharply shrink what a lower-earning spouse receives.
A cautionary case from New Hampshire. Deborah Munson and Coralee Beal lived together from 1993 and formalized their relationship only after New Hampshire allowed it. The trial court treated theirs as a short-term marriage. It gave Beal about 12% of the marital property and $500 a month in alimony for five years. In 2016, the New Hampshire Supreme Court vacated those awards. It held that judges may consider premarital cohabitation when dividing property and setting alimony.
A different approach in Colorado. In In re Marriage of LaFleur & Pyfer (2021), Colorado's Supreme Court held that a same-sex couple could have formed a common-law marriage before same-sex marriage was legal there. The ban was unconstitutional, so it could not stand in the way.
How this plays out locally:
- Maryland divides "marital property" (generally, property acquired during the marriage) under Family Law § 8-205. Alimony is governed by § 11-106. Both statutes list the length of the marriage as a factor. Both also let the court weigh contributions, financial circumstances, and other relevant facts. That gives your attorney room to present the full history of your partnership, including joint homes, shared accounts, and career sacrifices.
- Maryland does not allow common-law marriages formed in Maryland. It does recognize those validly formed in places that allow them.
- DC is one of the few places that still recognizes common-law marriage. A couple who lived in DC and held themselves out as spouses may argue their marriage began earlier than the license date. That argument can move the line on what counts as marital property and how long alimony lasts (D.C. Code §§ 16-910, 16-913).
Gather the evidence early: joint leases or deeds, beneficiary designations, domestic partnership registrations, commitment ceremony records, and shared finances.
Protecting Yourself in a High-Conflict Same-Sex Divorce
- Secure your parentage now. If you have not completed an adoption or parentage judgment, talk to a lawyer before the case escalates.
- Keep communication in writing. Use a co-parenting app and keep messages short and child-focused. Judges read these messages.
- Never withhold the child or relocate without an order. Self-help can cost you custody.
- Take threats seriously. Threats to "out" a spouse to an employer or family, or to reveal someone's health information, can be part of a pattern of coercive control. Both Maryland and DC courts can issue protective orders.
- Document your relationship history. Build a timeline from the day you moved in together, not just your wedding day.
- Stay off social media. Posts about your spouse or the case often show up as exhibits.
Frequently Asked Questions
Is same-sex divorce different from other divorces in Maryland? No. The same statutes and courts apply. Parentage questions and how to treat years together before marriage tend to come up more often.
How long must we be separated to divorce in Maryland? Only six months for the separation ground. Irreconcilable differences and mutual consent require no waiting period.
Can I get custody if I'm not my child's biological parent? Often, yes. You may be a legal parent through marriage, assisted-reproduction consent, or adoption. Even if not, you may qualify as a de facto parent under Conover in Maryland or D.C. Code § 16-831.01 in DC.
Does DC require a separation period? No. Since January 2024, one spouse only needs to say they no longer wish to stay married, after meeting DC's six-month residency rule.
Talk to a Maryland and DC Family Law Attorney
High-conflict divorces reward preparation and punish mistakes. The Law Offices of Thomas Stahl in Columbia, Maryland, represents clients throughout Maryland and the District of Columbia in contested divorce, custody, de facto parent, and property disputes. We help LGBTQ+ spouses and parents protect their children and their futures. Call 443-300-9208 today to schedule a confidential consultation.
This article provides general information about Maryland and District of Columbia law as of November 2026. It is not legal advice and does not create an attorney-client relationship. Every case depends on its own facts. Please consult an attorney about your situation.